Sole Scapegoat for 49ers' Super Bowl Defeat: Not Kyle Shanahan

Mahomes' agility tests 49ers' defense in pivotal moments.

by Nouman Rasool
Sole Scapegoat for 49ers' Super Bowl Defeat: Not Kyle Shanahan
© Grant Halverson/Getty Images

In a pivotal moment that could have sealed a Super Bowl victory for the San Francisco 49ers, the decision-making on the field came under intense scrutiny, particularly during the Kansas City Chiefs' crucial overtime drive.

As the Chiefs faced a third-and-6 near midfield, 49ers defensive coordinator Steve Wilks opted for a daring cover-zero blitz against the formidable Patrick Mahomes, a choice that raised eyebrows, considering the high stakes.

49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan, sensing the potential fallout from Wilks' aggressive strategy, called a timeout in a bid to reassess the situation. This wasn't the first instance this season where Wilks leaned towards a cover-zero in critical moments, highlighting a pattern in his play-calling.

Despite the timeout, Mahomes connected with rookie Rashee Rice for a significant 13-yard gain, marking the Chiefs' eighth successful third-down conversion of the game and sustaining a drive that, by all accounts, should have concluded earlier.

Wilks' Strategy Backfires

Wilks' decision-making was further questioned when Mahomes exploited gaps in the 49ers' defense, using his agility to secure crucial yards on the ground, notably on a fourth-and-1 situation that kept the Chiefs' aspirations alive.

While Wilks orchestrated a commendable defensive strategy through the first three quarters, limiting the Chiefs to modest gains, the tide turned in the final quarter and overtime. The Chiefs amassed 208 yards, significantly altering the game's momentum and ultimately leading to their scoring drives, which were notably longer and more fruitful than their earlier efforts.

Although Shanahan's choice to lean heavily on passing plays in the second half could be debated, it was ultimately Wilks' defensive calls that allowed the Chiefs to claw back into the game. Critical conversions on third down, including a pivotal 22-yard completion to Travis Kelce, and the Chiefs' relentless advance in overtime underscored the defensive lapses that plagued the 49ers when it mattered most.

The aftermath of the game left many pointing fingers at Wilks' play-calling, especially in light of the defensive successes earlier in the game. As the dust settles, the 49ers are left to ponder what might have been, had their defensive strategies held firm in the face of Mahomes' late-game heroics.

Super Bowl