Terry McAulay Highlights Officiating Error in Chiefs-Dolphins Clash

Expert Analyst Challenges Officiating in High-Stakes Playoff Game.

by Nouman Rasool
Terry McAulay Highlights Officiating Error in Chiefs-Dolphins Clash
© Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

In a dramatic Wild Card showdown, the Kansas City Chiefs' star quarterback, Patrick Mahomes, faced not only the formidable Miami Dolphins but also an unusual equipment hiccup that sparked controversy. The game, which aired on NBC, saw NFL rules analyst Terry McAulay highlighting a contentious officiating decision that bypassed standard protocol.

The focal point of the debate occurred in the third quarter following a collision involving Mahomes and Dolphins' DeShon Elliott. Viewers witnessed a piece of Mahomes' helmet dislodging, a sign of apparent equipment failure.

The Chiefs' quarterback continued for two more plays before officials acknowledged the issue, instructing him to replace his helmet.

NFL rules dictate clear procedures for such scenarios: a player with malfunctioning equipment must either exit the game temporarily or a timeout must be called to address the issue.

However, in this instance, neither course was followed. Officials paused the game, allowing Mahomes to swap helmets without costing the Chiefs a timeout, a move that deviated from typical practices. Commentator Mike Tirico was the first to note this anomaly, expressing surprise over the officials' decision to halt the game for equipment change without enforcing a timeout.

"You don’t see that without them having to take a timeout. I know it’s Mahomes, but I’m surprised they didn’t have to take a timeout to do that," Tirico remarked during the broadcast.

McAulay Questions Call

McAulay, brought in for expert analysis, concurred with Tirico's observations, pointing out the irregularity of the situation.

"He really should have to go out or they take a time-out," McAulay asserted, directly questioning the on-field decision. Despite the controversial call, the Chiefs settled for a field goal following an incomplete pass in the subsequent play, suggesting that the officiating oversight had a limited impact on the game's outcome.

Nonetheless, the incident raises questions about consistency in rule enforcement, especially in high-stakes situations. One can only speculate how the game might have unfolded differently had Mahomes been sidelined for a play or if the Chiefs had been compelled to use a timeout.

Chiefs Dolphins