Jason Garrett Criticized for Announcing in Chiefs-Dolphins Game

Unexpected twists marked the recent NFL playoff broadcast.

by Nouman Rasool
Jason Garrett Criticized for Announcing in Chiefs-Dolphins Game
© Wesley Hitt/Getty Images

In a pivotal playoff clash between the Kansas City Chiefs and Miami Dolphins, the NFL and NBC's choice of Jason Garrett as a color commentator for the Peacock streaming service left much to be desired. Unfortunately, the game, a highlight of the NFL postseason, became notable for Garrett's lackluster and often perplexing commentary, leaving fans and viewers questioning the decision-making behind the broadcasting team.

To put it mildly, Garrett's commentary throughout the game was underwhelming. His descriptions of the on-field action were tepid and unimaginative, lacking the insight and excitement one expects from a seasoned commentator.

A prime example of this was his reference to Patrick Mahomes, a quarterback renowned for his athletic prowess, as a "sneaky good athlete" – a comment that seemed to betray a lack of familiarity with one of the NFL's brightest stars.

Garrett's Bizarre Commentary

Moreover, Garrett's analysis often veered into the bizarre, including a puzzling allusion to a song by Vitamin C, remembered for its nostalgia about high school years. This odd reference did little to enhance the broadcast, leaving viewers scratching their heads.

Such moments underscored a broader issue with Garrett's commentary style: a tendency to opt for the most straightforward, uninspired descriptions of the game's events. Throughout the broadcast, Garrett's commentary flip-flopped, showing a lack of consistency and depth in his analysis.

Instead of adding the 'color' that his role demands, he seemed to follow a script more suited to a robotic, binary code-driven entity than a commentator capable of engaging with a human audience. The reaction from NFL fans was swift and unforgiving.

Social media platforms were abuzz with criticisms of Garrett's performance, with many expressing frustration over the subpar quality of the commentary during such a high-stakes game. Fans lamented the missed opportunity to enhance the viewing experience with insightful, dynamic, and engaging commentary, which has become a staple expectation in modern sports broadcasting.

This incident serves as a reminder of commentators' critical role in shaping the sports viewing experience. As the NFL continues to expand its audience, particularly through streaming platforms like Peacock, the need for high-caliber commentary talent becomes increasingly paramount.

The league and its broadcasting partners must recognize that the commentator's voice is not just a background element but a central part of the game-day experience for fans across the globe.

Chiefs Dolphins