Byron Scott Doubts JJ Redick's Fit for Lakers Coach Due to Lack of Experience

Exploring viable leadership options for the Lakers' future.

by Nouman Rasool
Byron Scott Doubts JJ Redick's Fit for Lakers Coach Due to Lack of Experience
© Tom Pennington/Getty Images

Former Los Angeles Lakers standout Byron Scott expresses reservations about JJ Redick stepping into the Lakers' head coaching role this offseason. The three-time NBA champion Scott, who understands the rigors of the job firsthand, questions whether Redick, lacking any coaching background, is prepared for such a demanding position.

In an impromptu discussion with TMZ, Scott pointed to the difficulties faced by those without prior coaching experience. "JJ has no coaching experience whatsoever, and it's a significant challenge to take on the role of a head coach for the first time," Scott explained.

He referenced Steve Nash's tenure with the Brooklyn Nets as a cautionary example, noting Nash's struggles despite his profound understanding of the game as a player.

Preferred Coaching Candidates

The search for the Lakers' next head coach is pivotal, and Scott believes the role should go to someone with a solid reputation within the NBA community.

He suggests Mark Jackson or Sam Cassell, both respected figures in the league, as more suitable candidates than Redick. "I respect what JJ has done, especially with his podcast, but leading a team is a different ball game," Scott added skeptically.

Scott's concerns are not without merit. Redick, primarily known today as an ESPN analyst and podcast host, has only coached at the high school level—a stark contrast to the NBA's competitive intensity. Furthermore, the Lakers have seen significant turnover in their coaching staff, cycling through three head coaches in just six years, highlighting the critical need for a reliable leader.

If Redick is chosen, Scott advises him to assemble a strong team of assistant coaches to help bridge his experience gap. "Choosing the right assistants could be crucial for easing the pressures of the job," said Scott, who even half-jokingly offered his services, drawing on his rich background that includes three NBA championships and a Coach of the Year award in 2008.

Regarding managing star players like LeBron James, Scott is somewhat optimistic about Redick's potential, citing the existing rapport between the two from their podcast interactions. "Their chemistry and relationship might actually benefit his transition into a head coaching role," he noted.

As the Lakers deliberate on their next move, the decision weighs heavily not just on the prospects of the coming season but also on the broader stability of the franchise. Scott's insights offer a cautionary perspective on the challenges of transitioning from player to coach, especially at the helm of one of the most scrutinized teams in professional sports.