Yankees vs. Rangers: Top 5 Reasons Why Montgomery Belongs in New York

From Growth to Glory: Montgomery's Rise in MLB

by Nouman Rasool
Yankees vs. Rangers: Top 5 Reasons Why Montgomery Belongs in New York
© Megan Briggs/Getty Images

In the dynamic world of Major League Baseball, left-handed ace Jordan Montgomery's 2023 season was nothing short of a rollercoaster. This remarkable journey took him from an underperforming team at the season's start to the pinnacle of baseball glory with a World Series victory.

Montgomery's Remarkable Journey

Montgomery's tenure with the New York Yankees, spanning from 2017 to 2022, was a period of significant growth. Here, he honed his skills, emerging as one of the premier starting pitchers in the league.

The 2022 season saw a pivotal moment when he was traded to the Cardinals, a move that sent outfielder Harrison Bader to the Yankees. However, his stint with the Cardinals was brief. Midway through the 2023 season, Montgomery found himself traded to the Texas Rangers.

His performance there was stellar, as evidenced by a 4-2 record and a commendable 2.79 ERA, culminating in a World Series triumph. As free agency looms, Montgomery faces a pivotal decision: rejoining the Rangers or returning to the New York Yankees.

The scales seem to tip towards the Bronx for the 31-year-old pitcher, and here's why. With the Yankees missing out on securing Yoshinobu Yamamoto, General Manager Brian Cashman is under pressure to appease the fan base with a high-profile pitching acquisition.

Cashman, who initially traded Montgomery, faced criticism during the pitcher's successful 2023 postseason. A return to the Bronx would likely be met with an attractive financial offer from the Yankees, hard for Montgomery to ignore.

Despite several changes in the Yankees’ roster since Montgomery's departure, many familiar faces remain. More crucially, Montgomery has an intimate understanding of pitching in the Yankee Stadium, known for its hitter-friendly dynamics.

It's an advantage that he wouldn't have at Globe Life Field, home of the Rangers. The Rangers, while having a formidable batting lineup, lack the same depth in their pitching staff. With key players like Martin Perez gone and Max Scherzer aging, the Rangers' pitching lacks the robustness of the Yankees.

Rejoining the Yankees would mean teaming up with 2023 AL Cy Young winner Gerrit Cole and a strong ensemble of pitchers, easing the pressure on Montgomery. The Yankees’ bullpen, with an ERA of 3.34, was a crucial factor in their success, outperforming the Rangers' relievers significantly.

This strong bullpen support is invaluable for starters like Montgomery, ensuring leads are maintained and providing much-needed backup. Finally, the New York Yankees are more than just a baseball team; they are an institution.

Playing for the Yankees offers a level of recognition and opportunity unmatched by other teams. Montgomery, having experienced the limelight in New York, may find the allure of returning to this iconic team irresistible. As Jordan Montgomery weighs his options, the Yankees present a compelling case for his return.

With financial incentives, familiar surroundings, a superior pitching squad, robust bullpen support, and the unmatched prestige of the Yankees, the Bronx seems to be calling him back for another chapter in his illustrious career.

Yankees Rangers